"The conflict resolution and the cozy illustrations make for a refreshingly thoughtful holiday tale. As sweet as Hanukkah gelt." – Kirkus Reviews
"...readers may suspect they're celebrating not just the story of Hanukkah, but also the wonder of their friendship." – Publisher's Weekly
"Young readers and listeners will enjoy the silliness, and possibly the knowledge that they have better memories or deduction skills than Charley. The solution Seymour suggests (don't try this at home) is reminiscent of the Hanukkah legend of the oil miracle." – The Horn Book Magazine
"An additional purchase for collections where Hanukkah stories are popular." – School Library Journal
"This is a warm story of friendship, creativity and having fun no matter the circumstances, this is a wonderful Hanukkah story that not only tells the story of the holiday, but centers the theme of friendship . . . This is a great read! Reviewer Rating: 5" – Children's Literature
"The illustrations are simplistic and colorful and will appeal to young children. This book is an appropriate fun additional purchase for Jewish, school, and public libraries which have substantial collections of Hanukkah stories." – Association of Jewish Libraries
